Forget about
modesty standards in society: Spectators, not the nursing
mothers, create the unease surrounding public breast-feeding,
some mothers say.
"I don't understand why they think
it's the breast-feeder's responsibility to ease their
discomfort," says Sandy Piderit, Ph.D., co-founder of the
Northeast Ohio Breastfeeding Education and Advocacy Network and
assistant professor of organizational behavior at Case Western
Reserve University in Cleveland.
"If you don't like watching a
woman breast-feed, then move," Piderit says.
Ohio is one of a handful of states that
recently passed legislation guaranteeing public breast-feeding
rights. Pennsylvania lawmakers are considering a similar
proposal.
Andy Steiner -- author of "Spilled
Milk: Breastfeeding Adventures and Advice from Less-Than-Perfect
Moms," which will be published later this month -- says
that no mothers intend to re-enact Janet Jackson's so-called
wardrobe malfunction last year, when her nipple became exposed
during a Super Bowl halftime show. Breast-feeding changes the
context of the situation, she says.
"The sexual image makes people
uncomfortable, but it's not the most sexy image of a breast that
you've ever seen," says Steiner, 37, of St. Paul, Minn. She
has two daughters -- Astrid, 5, and Iris, 15 months -- whom she
discreetly breast-fed in public, usually unbeknownst to others.
"There's nothing to be ashamed
of," she says.
Many medical professionals and women
who breast-feed swear by the practice, saying it offers the best
nourishment and nurturing for infants and it honors human
biological design. The American Academy of Pediatrics recommends
that mothers exclusively breast-feed their babies for the first
six months, and continue with at least some nursing through the
first year.
Unless mothers with hungry newborns
become hermits, advocates say, what else can they do but
breast-feed outside the home?
"We're talking about feeding our
babies ... we're talking about the best meal you can give them
in the first months of their lives," says Dawn Ferrell,
owner of Avery Baby Care in Pine. She carries supplies such as
breast pumps, baby slings and nursing bras.
"It shouldn't be something that's
frowned upon," she says. "Half the time, you don't
even know if a woman is nursing. They're covering up and trying
to be as discreet as possible."
Many products are available to help
women discreetly nurse, including nursing apparel -- such as
dresses and shirts with flaps that hide the breast and baby's
head -- and simple towels and blankets.
"You just need to get the baby
close enough to you," says Anna Heh, a certified lactation
consultant with Magee Women's Hospital in Oakland. "Once
they're on, their head usually obscures any view of your breast
that might be showing."
Heh, 55, of Pleasant Hills, says she
would receive compliments from women and men when she nursed her
four children -- now grown -- in public. Meanwhile, Heh's
father-in-law had no idea when she was breastfeeding in front of
him.
If a woman is feeling self-conscious
about trying to breast-feed in public for the first time, she
should practice first in front of a mirror, so she can see what
others will see and make any adjustments, Heh says.
Rhonda Olshanski -- who nursed her
21-month-old daughter, Manya, and is now pregnant -- nurses
discreetly in public. She says baby formula pales in comparison
to the benefits of breast milk. Yet Olshanski, of North
Huntingdon, always uses a cover or nursing shirt, and says
others should do the same.
"You should try to be respectful
of other people's feelings," says Olshanski, 31.
"While I think that you absolutely have the right to
breast-feed in public, you also have a responsibility to make
sure it isn't really in-your-face."
Many women, such as Susan Hodil, of
Hampton, choose not to breast-feed in public because they feel
the practice -- though not shameful -- is private. Hodil, 34,
breast-fed all three of her children -- Harry, 7, Emma, 5, and
Olivia, who is 8 months old and being weaned. Hodil breast-fed
them, though, either at home or in a private location outside
the home, and says she thought people felt uncomfortable with
watching nursing in public.
"I don't think it's wrong ... but
there needs to be common sense used," Hodil says.
"Most people make an effort to go someplace private. You
can't make people uncomfortable for the sake of your
convenience."
Some people who oppose public
breast-feeding say women need not feel so inconvenienced: Why
not bring a bottle, either with pumped breast milk or formula,
on outings? Why not excuse yourself to go someplace private,
like a car or the bathroom?
Public breast-feeding proponents say
the situation is not that simple.
"Bathrooms aren't the cleanest
place in the world," Ferrell says. "Would you want to
eat in the bathroom?"
Many babies also do not adjust well to
bottle-feeding, making it difficult to substitute, says Debra
Gilbert Rosenberg, 53. She is the author of "Motherhood
Without Guilt" and "The New Mom's Companion," and
a licensed clinical social worker in Oak Park, Ill. "If
you're going to feed an infant, it's not always convenient to be
at home, and it's inconvenient to find a secluded, private
place."
Still, women should not judge each
other, she says. Many mothers take an evangelical approach in
their beliefs, and frown upon women who don't breast-feed all
the time. Many women, for a variety of reasons, need to use
bottles and formula exclusively.
"I think it's important to
breast-feed if you can, but if you can't, you can't,"
Rosenberg says.
Joanne Gilbert, Ph.D. -- professor of
communications and co-director of women's studies at Alma
College in Alma, Mich. -- agrees.
"It's unfortunate when women
pressure other women to conform to anyone's standards,"
Gilbert says. "That's so counterproductive to the whole
concept of feminism, sisterhood and supporting each other."
Award recognizes
businesses that cater to nursing moms
One of the reasons women breast-feed in
public is the lack of appropriate places to nurse outside the
home, says Oak Park, Ill., author Debra Gilbert Rosenberg. Yet
many businesses -- aware of the needs of female patrons and
employees -- are providing designated areas for convenient
breast-feeding and pumping, with only fellow moms as company.
"Moms are very grateful to have a
place to go," Rosenberg says.
A Squirrel Hill synagogue, Shaare Torah
Congregation, this month received the 10th Annual Breastfeeding
Friendly Place Award from the Allegheny County Health
Department. The agency recognizes businesses and other places
that make an extra effort to accommodate breast-feeding mothers,
spokesman Dave Zazac says.
The synagogue's "Mommy and
Me" room, which opened about a year and a half ago, is the
result of efforts by the many congregation members who are
nursing mothers and their husbands, says Linda Pasternak, office
manager. The carpeted room is about the size of a small
classroom and includes a couch, chair, refrigerator and changing
table.
"It's important for the women to
feel there's someplace they can go and be comfortable,"
Pasternak says. "This is someplace that the women can go
and be private and talk among themselves."
-- Kellie B. Gormly